Close Menu
Pest MagazinePest Magazine
  • News
    • National Pest Awards
    • BPCA
    • NPTA
    • Companies
    • Local Authority
    • Natural England
    • HSE
    • People
    • Products
    • Best Practice
    • Brexit
    • COVID-19
  • Species
    • Rodents
    • Insects
    • Birds
    • Mammals
  • Magazines
    • June/July 2025
    • April / May 2025
    • Feb / March 2025
    • Dec 2024 / Jan 2025
    • Oct / Nov 2024
    • Aug / Sept 2024
  • Library
    • Inserts
    • Supplements
  • Professional Development
    • BASIS
    • Research
    • Stewardship
    • Training
  • Pest Test
  • Jobs
    • View All Jobs
  • Key Supporters
    • Bábolna Bio
    • Bell Laboratories
    • Pelsis
    • Envu
    • Lodi UK
    • PelGar International
    • Russell IPM
    • Syngenta
X (Twitter) LinkedIn
  • Sign-up for weekly news emails
  • Subscribe to Pest Magazine
  • About Us
    • Technical Advisory Board
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Pest Test Log-In
Pest MagazinePest Magazine
  • News
    • National Pest Awards
    • BPCA
    • NPTA
    • Companies
    • Local Authority
    • Natural England
    • HSE
    • People
    • Products
    • Best Practice
    • Brexit
    • COVID-19
  • Species
    1. Rodents
    2. Insects
    3. Birds
    4. Mammals
    5. View All

    Helping a luxury car showroom eradicate an infestation and steer clear of rodents

    25 March 2024

    Case Study – Freeing a pig farm of a severe rodent infestation in just 10 days

    11 May 2023

    Chinese takeaway issues apology after video of rats and raw chicken emerges

    14 July 2021

    Republic of Ireland rodent callouts jump 35%

    25 June 2021

    13 confirmed sightings of yellow-legged hornets so far in 2025

    13 May 2025

    Red Spider Mites on the hunt for spaces to hibernate

    3 December 2024

    Rentokil encourages vigilance as wasp activity increases ahead of the early autumn nesting period

    25 September 2024

    Rentokil warns of a surge in biting insects as humid weather continues

    3 September 2024

    Worcester City Council increases budget to control gull numbers by £35,000

    26 October 2022

    BPCA urges householders and businesses to seek professional advice if birds are becoming a problem

    3 May 2022

    NatureScot restricts the use of general licences on Lochan Estate in Perthshire

    7 February 2022

    Natural Resources Wales confirms Welsh general licence extension until June 2022

    17 December 2021

    Conservation charity warns of need for joined-up approach and a fast-track to effective grey squirrel controls

    30 May 2025

    Squirrel charity welcomes new legislation on use of gene editing

    14 June 2022

    Ferrets to be removed as permitted target species for the DOC 250 spring trap

    13 April 2021

    Charity says planting of 30,000 hectares of trees must be matched by grey squirrel control

    10 February 2021

    Conservation charity warns of need for joined-up approach and a fast-track to effective grey squirrel controls

    30 May 2025

    13 confirmed sightings of yellow-legged hornets so far in 2025

    13 May 2025

    Red Spider Mites on the hunt for spaces to hibernate

    3 December 2024

    Rentokil encourages vigilance as wasp activity increases ahead of the early autumn nesting period

    25 September 2024
  • Magazines
    1. June/July 2025
    2. April / May 2025
    3. Feb / March 2025
    4. Dec 2024 / Jan 2025
    5. Oct / Nov 2024
    6. Aug / Sept 2024
    Featured

    Pest 99: June/July 2025

    By Simon King10 June 2025
    Recent

    Pest 99: June/July 2025

    10 June 2025

    Pest 98: April / May 2025

    8 April 2025

    Pest 97: February / March 2025

    12 February 2025
  • Library
    • Inserts
    • Supplements
  • Professional Development
    • BASIS
    • Research
    • Stewardship
    • Training
  • Pest Test
  • Jobs
    • View All Jobs
  • Key Supporters
    • Bábolna Bio
    • Bell Laboratories
    • Pelsis
    • Envu
    • Lodi UK
    • PelGar International
    • Russell IPM
    • Syngenta
Pest MagazinePest Magazine
Rodents

Pests have legal rights too

Pest WritersBy Pest Writers29 January 2015No Comments5 Mins Read
LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email

The recent legal case of the Staffordshire window cleaner who caught, and subsequently drowned, a squirrel he trapped in his own garden has raised a whole series of questions.

In this widely reported test case brought by the RSPCA, Raymond Elliott, pleaded guilty for causing a wild animal ‘unnecessary suffering’ under the Animal Welfare Act 2006. Mr Elliot received a six-month conditional discharge and was ordered to pay £1,547 to cover investigation and legal costs incurred by the RSPCA.

To read the full story as reported by The Daily Telegraph on 19 July 2010 click here.

The Animal Welfare Act 2006 states that it is illegal to cause ‘unnecessary suffering’ to all wild animals caught in live capture traps and deemed under the control of man.

This obviously raises serious implications for all those within pest control who are called upon to deal with live animals – or in pest control terms – ‘pests’. Captured squirrels, foxes, rabbits and moles rapidly spring to mind. But it would also cover all rodents (rats and mice) as well as all birds. Help!

What is your opinion? At Pestwe are interested in what you think – so please click here and let us know.

Don’t worry – any comments published in any form will be anonymous.

To get you thinking…
To get your ”grey matter” going, wildlife expert, Paul Butt, has put together a few personal thoughts (not necessarily official Natural England/Defra opinions) to debate the issues raised around live capture trapping and dealing with captured animals.

“The Staffordshire case raises the contentious issue of humane dispatch or other means of dealing with pest species. It also highlights the problems that arise where householders and others inexperienced in handling trapped animals use live capture cage traps that are freely available from garden centres, DIY stores and hardware shops. Sometimes described as ‘humane’ there is usually no advice or guidance supplied on how to deal with the captured animal.

Taking squirrels as the example, drowning is generally viewed as an inhumane method of killing any animal. An opinion based on observations of the period of time, often several minutes during which the subject is seen to struggle. Dispatching by running the squirrel into a sack and delivering a blow to the head is seen as ‘barbaric’ by the general public and others but is widely used as the technique of choice in forestry protection and other pest control activities. Experience has shown that used correctly this produces a swift kill with the minimum of stress imposed on the animal. No special equipment is required and there are none of the complications where the use of a firearm is involved.

  

Grey squirel Once caught – what next? 

Paul Butt 
Paul Butt raises some pertinent points 

There appears to be some misunderstanding where it is recommended or proposed that more than one blow is delivered using this technique and a suggestion that this could be an offence. It is good practice to deliver the first blow with the intention of this resulting in the required lethal effect but with a second delivered immediately after the first before checking that the animal is dead. This provides additional ‘insurance’ that the squirrel has been swiftly killed.

Trying to accurately shoot a squirrel in a trap requires patience; the typical cage trap is not designed to enable the animal to be confined to one area such as is found where ‘squeeze traps’ are used in other trapping work. This is made more difficult when an air rifle is used.

Let’s consider the proposal to seek the services of a vet to dispatch the squirrel. Defining stress is difficult but surely this aspect has to be taken into account; transporting the unfortunate animal in the trap some distance within a vehicle, exposure to daylight, heat/cold, arriving at and waiting in an alien, hostile environment (a vet surgery with all its accompanying smells & noises) to be followed by the administration of a lethal injection that can be problematic to deliver and could result in a period of time before death, will all result in significant stress that could be avoided.

Provisions of The Animal Welfare Act 2006 should be considered in respect of all trapping operations where once caught, the animal is deemed to be ‘under the control of man’ and therefore subject to this legislation.

It would seem to be a sound principle that no one should set any live capture cage trap for all potential target species including rodents, feral mink, grey squirrels, rabbits and foxes where there is the intention/requirement to kill any captured unless they have made appropriate provision (techniques will vary according to the species) for these animals to be humanely dispatched by either themselves or another party who are competent and able to undertake this task.

As a principle, I take the view that in order to minimise stress that wherever possible, captured animals should be dispatched at the trapping site so avoiding the requirement to transport & move the animals. Clients and customers may not take kindly to this (preferring ‘out of sight out of mind’) but don’t they need to take some responsibility in assisting with welfare and related aspects?”

Share. LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Email
Previous ArticleCelebrations at Russell IPM for Queen’s award
Next Article Seminar and technical programme for PestEx 2015 announced
Pest Writers

Read Similar Stories

Helping a luxury car showroom eradicate an infestation and steer clear of rodents

Case Study – Freeing a pig farm of a severe rodent infestation in just 10 days

Chinese takeaway issues apology after video of rats and raw chicken emerges

Latest Stories

A global gathering at ICUP in Sweden

10 July 2025

Finalists announced for the National Pest Awards 2025

9 July 2025

BPCA to host non-member open evening next week

9 July 2025
Key Supporters
© 2025 Lewis Business Media. All Rights Reserved.
Lewis Business Media, Suite A, Arun House, Office Village, River Way, Uckfield, TN22 1SL

Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions

  • National Pest Awards
  • OvertheCounter
  • Pet Business World

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.